|
|
 |
| Year |
American League |
National League |
| 1949 |
Roy Sievers |
Don Newcombe |
| 1950 |
Walt Dropo |
Sam Jethroe |
| 1951 |
Gil McDougald |
Willie Mays |
| 1952 |
Harry Byrd |
Joe Black |
| 1953 |
Harvey Kuenn |
Jim Gilliam |
| 1954 |
Bob Grim |
Wally Moon |
| 1955 |
Herb Score |
Bill Virdon |
| 1956 |
Luis Aparicio |
Frank Robinson |
| 1957 |
Tony Kubek |
Jack Sanford |
| 1958 |
Albie Pearson |
Orlando Cepeda |
| 1959 |
Bob Allison |
Willie McCovey |
| 1960 |
Ron Hansen |
Frank Howard |
| 1961 |
Don Schwall |
Billy Williams |
| 1962 |
Tom Tresh |
Ken Hubbs |
| 1963 |
Gary Peters |
Pete Rose |
| 1964 |
Tony Oliva |
Dick Allen |
| 1965 |
Curt Blefary |
Jim Lefebvre |
| 1966 |
Tommie Agee |
Tommy Helms |
| 1967 |
Rod Carew |
Tom Seaver |
| 1968 |
Stan Bahnsen |
Johnny Bench |
| 1969 |
Lou Piniella |
Ted Sizemore |
| 1970 |
Thurman Munson |
Carl Morton |
| 1971 |
Chris Chambliss |
Earl Williams |
| 1972 |
Carlton Fisk |
Jon Matlack |
| 1973 |
Al Bumbry |
Gary Matthews |
| 1974 |
Mike Hargrove |
Bake McBride |
| 1975 |
Fred Lynn |
John Montefusco |
| 1976 |
Mark Fidrych |
Butch Metzger;
Pat Zachry |
| 1977 |
Eddie Murray |
Andre Dawson |
| 1978 |
Lou Whitaker |
Bob Horner |
| 1979 |
John Castino;
Alfredo Griffin |
Rick Sutcliffe |
| 1980 |
Joe Charboneau |
Steve Howe |
| 1981 |
Dave Righetti |
Fernando Valenzuela |
| 1982 |
Cal Ripken, Jr. |
Steve Sax |
| 1983 |
Ron Kittle |
Darryl Strawberry |
| 1984 |
Alvin Davis |
Dwight Gooden |
| 1985 |
Ozzie Guillen |
Vince Coleman |
| 1986 |
Jose Canseco |
Todd Worrell |
| 1987 |
Mark McGwire |
Benito Santiago |
| 1988 |
Walt Weiss |
Chris Sabo |
| 1989 |
Gregg Olson |
Jerome Walton |
| 1990 |
Sandy Alomar, Jr. |
David Justice |
| 1991 |
Chuck Knoblauch |
Jeff Bagwell |
| 1992 |
Pat Listach |
Eric Karros |
| 1993 |
Tim Salmon |
Mike Piazza |
| 1994 |
Bob Hamelin |
Raul Mondesi |
| 1995 |
Marty Cordova |
Hideo Nomo |
| 1996 |
Derek Jeter |
Todd Hollandsworth |
| 1997 |
Nomar Garciaparra |
Scott Rolen |
| 1998 |
Ben Grieve |
Kerry Wood |
| 1999 |
Carlos Beltran |
Scott Williamson |
| 2000 |
Kazuhiro Sasaki |
Rafael Furcal |
| 2001 |
Ichiro Suzuki |
Albert Pujols |
| 2002 |
Eric Hinske |
Jason Jennings |
| 2003 |
Angel Berroa |
Dontrelle Willis |
| 2004 |
Bobby Crosby |
Jason Bay |
| 2005 |
Huston Street |
Ryan Howard |
|
