| Rank |
Player |
Wins |
| 1 |
Charles Radbourn |
59 |
| 2 |
Al Spalding |
55 |
| 3 |
John Clarkson |
53 |
| 4 |
Guy Hecker |
52 |
| 5 |
Al Spalding |
52 |
| 6 |
John Clarkson |
49 |
| 7 |
Charlie Buffinton |
48 |
| 8 |
Charles Radbourn |
48 |
| 9 |
John Ward |
47 |
| 10 |
Al Spalding |
47 |
| 11 |
Matt Kilroy |
46 |
| 12 |
Pud Galvin |
46 |
| 13 |
Pud Galvin |
46 |
| 14 |
George Bradley |
45 |
| 15 |
Silver King |
45 |
| 16 |
Jim McCormick |
45 |
| 17 |
Mickey Welch |
44 |
| 18 |
Bill Hutchison |
44 |
| 19 |
Dick McBride |
44 |
| 20 |
Will White |
43 |
| 21 |
Tommy Bond |
43 |
| 22 |
Larry Corcoran |
43 |
| 23 |
Will White |
43 |
| 24 |
Billy Taylor |
43 |
| 25 |
Tim Keefe |
42 |
| 26 |
Lady Baldwin |
42 |
| 27 |
Bill Hutchison |
42 |
| 28 |
Bobby Mathews |
42 |
| 29 |
Tim Keefe |
41 |
| 30 |
Al Spalding |
41 |
| 31 |
Dave Foutz |
41 |
| 32 |
Jack Chesbro |
41 |
| 33 |
Charlie Sweeney |
41 |
| 34 |
Ed Morris |
41 |
| 35 |
Ed Walsh |
40 |
| 36 |
Tommy Bond |
40 |
| 37 |
Jim McCormick |
40 |
| 38 |
Bob Caruthers |
40 |
| 39 |
Bill Sweeney |
40 |
| 40 |
Bob Caruthers |
40 |
| 41 |
Will White |
40 |
| 42 |
Tommy Bond |
40 |
| 43 |
Mickey Welch |
39 |
| 44 |
John Ward |
39 |
| 45 |
Ed Morris |
39 |
| 46 |
Toad Ramsey |
38 |
| 47 |
Al Spalding |
38 |
| 48 |
John Clarkson |
38 |
| 49 |
Kid Gleason |
38 |
| 50 |
Tim Keefe |
37 |
|